Skip to content
Owen Caldwell

Walnut · Delivered June 2025

Catskill Dining Table.

A six-seat dining table with hand-planed top and breadboard ends.

Catskill Dining Table
Materials
Walnut
Joinery
Mortise & tenon, breadboard ends
Dimensions
84 × 38 × 30 in.
Price
$7,420
Lead time
Delivered in 18 weeks

About this piece

About this piece

The Catskill Dining Table is an eight-seat walnut table with breadboard ends and a hand-planed top. Bookmatched from a single 5/4 walnut slab I'd been drying for three years. The pinned breadboards let the top move seasonally without splitting the ends.

The base is a trestle in the same walnut, joined with through-tenons wedged in oak. Everything is finished in hand-rubbed oil. Seats eight with room, and holds up to a family for a decade of dinners.

From the client

From the client

The walnut table is the first piece of furniture we've owned that our kids fight over sitting at. Ten years from now they'll still be arguing about it.

Delivered June 2025, Beacon NY

Case study

The brief

What the client asked for, in their own words.

Sarah reached out in the fall of 2024. She and her husband had bought a 1920s farmhouse in Beacon and were mid-renovation. The dining room would be the first finished space, and she wanted the table in it to belong to the room the way the original floors and window casings did.

Her brief was specific. Eighty-four inches long, to seat eight without the leaves. Walnut. Legs at the corners, not a pedestal, because the whole family cooks together and nothing should catch a knee. She wanted the joinery to read, and she wanted to see the top move with the seasons.

She is an architect, which is why she said the thing that made me say yes to the timeline: "I don't need it fast. I need it right, and I need to understand why every piece of it is where it is."

Design decisions

Design decisions

Every choice that shaped the piece, and why it went that way.

  1. 01

    Breadboard ends over sliding dovetails

    An 84-inch top will move nearly a quarter inch across the grain between a dry January and a wet August. Breadboards pinned through elongated slots let the top expand and contract without splitting the end grain. Sliding dovetails would have worked too, but breadboards read on the top surface, and Sarah wanted to see the mechanism.

  2. 02

    Mortise-and-tenon apron, drawbored

    The apron is joined to the legs with through-mortises and drawbored tenons. No metal fasteners, no hidden hardware. When the joint eventually loosens, in fifty or a hundred years, someone can knock the pin out, pare the tenon, and put it back. That is the whole reason to build in solid wood.

  3. 03

    Straight tapered legs over turned

    The farmhouse was built by carpenters, not cabinetmakers. Its material vocabulary is honest and rectilinear. A turned leg would have read as a decorative gesture in that room. A straight taper, cut on the bandsaw and hand-planed, matches the language of the door casings.

  4. 04

    Hand-rubbed oil over film finish

    A lacquered film finish would be tougher for the first year and start failing at the edges by year five. Hard wax oil is softer on the surface and infinitely repairable in place. When a hot dish leaves a ring, Sarah can knock it back with a green pad and a rag of oil. The finish ages with the piece rather than sitting on top of it.

Materials and sourcing

Materials and sourcing

Where the wood came from, and how it got to the shop.

The walnut came from Reed & Sons, a family-owned mill in central Pennsylvania I've bought from for eight years. The trees were felled on a farm outside Danville in 2021 and air-dried on stickered stacks for three years before Reed's kiln brought them to eight percent moisture.

I drove down in February 2025 and picked out three eight-quarter slabs from the same tree. Two went into the top, bookmatched down the center. The third came back with me and is drying under weight in the shop, waiting for a bench or a cabinet from the same run. Sarah's grandchildren, if it comes to that, can commission something out of the same wood.

Build

Build

Milestones from first sketch to finish coat.

  1. Week 1

    Client visit and first sketches

    Two hours in the dining room measuring casing reveals and floor plank widths. Sent three thumbnail sketches by the end of the week.

  2. Week 3

    Measured drawings and wood selection

    Drove to Reed & Sons in Danville. Picked three slabs from the same tree. Sarah approved the bookmatch off a phone photo the same afternoon.

  3. Week 5

    Rough milling and jointing

    Slabs flattened on the router sled, then jointed and thicknessed to 15/16. Stickered in the shop for two weeks to let any residual movement settle before final dimensioning.

  4. Week 7

    Apron mortises and leg tenons

    Through-mortises chopped by hand, drawbore holes offset by a thirty-second. Legs tapered on the bandsaw, cleaned up with a jointer plane.

  5. Week 9

    Top glued, breadboard ends cut

    Bookmatch glued in a single pass, five clamps, no cauls. Breadboards joined with a stopped tongue-and-groove, pinned through three elongated slots per end.

  6. Week 12

    Hand-planing and finish

    Top flattened with a jointer plane, then smoothed with a #4. Six coats of hard wax oil, wet-sanded between the third and fourth, one week of cure between each coat.

Catskill Dining Table, case-study image 1
Catskill Dining Table, case-study image 2
Catskill Dining Table, case-study image 3

Delivery

Delivery

The day the piece went into the room it was built for.

I delivered the table myself in a rented Sprinter on the fourteenth of June. Modern Movers was on standby if the piece had been any bigger, but at eighty-four inches it fit through the front door with a quarter inch on each side of the jamb.

Install ran three hours, most of which was moving the old table out and dialing the leveler feet. Their kids sat down before I'd finished packing the moving blankets, elbows on the top.

Living with it

Living with it

A year in the room. How the piece has held up.

I stopped by in May 2026, almost a year to the day, to look at how the piece was settling in. The top had moved about three sixteenths across the grain, exactly what I'd allowed for in the breadboard slots. Two heat rings from a Dutch oven had come back under a light pass of oil. The finish had begun to darken the way walnut does in a room with morning light.

Sarah wrote a few weeks later, after they'd hosted a birthday for one of their kids:

The walnut table is the first piece of furniture we've owned that our kids fight over sitting at. Ten years from now they'll still be arguing about it.

Begin

Ask about a catskill dining table.

Sizes, species, and finishes can be adapted. I reply within two business days.

More work